PC

  News 
  Reviews
  Previews
  Hardware
  Interviews
  All Features

Areas

  3DS
  Android
  iPad
  iPhone
  Mac
  PC
  PlayStation 3
  PlayStation 4
  Switch
  Vita
  Wii U
  Xbox 360
  Xbox One
  Media
  Archives
  Search
  Contests

 

Secret of the Silver Earring

Score: 90%
ESRB: Teen
Publisher: Ubisoft Entertainment
Developer: Frogwares
Media: CD/2
Players: 1
Genre: Adventure

Graphics & Sound:

Take control of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s legendary detective, Sherlock Holmes, in an adventure game that will put your deductive skills to the test.

Secret of the Silver Earring’s graphical prowess is fairly good. The locations are expansive with a wealth of detail every time you turn around. The models are also well done. I especially liked the slim-and-trim rendition of Dr. Watson, as opposed to the short and pudgy versions you typically see in movies and other medias. I mean, come on people, Watson was a military man. I’m not saying he was a beefed-up muscle man -- but he definitely wasn’t the dim-witted portly person that is seen everywhere.

Though the characters themselves look good, the animation is stiff and seems very unnatural. Another problem in the animation department was the lip-synching. In a game where you will end up talking to everybody you meet (not to mention having lengthy conversations in the in-game cut-scenes), it would have been nice for the mouth to do more than just open and close as they talked.

The background music is very heavy on the violins (to help Holmes think of course). But at times, the music gets too overpowering to let you think -– ironic, ain’t it? The voice acting is excellent, both for the voices portraying the regular characters and the new ones for this mystery.


Gameplay:

Sherlock Holmes has been invited to enjoy an evening at the house of Sir Melvyn Bromsby. The event is his daughter’s birthday. But the esteemed business man is shot and killed, and it seems like the daughter is the prime suspect. Of course, it’s up to the legendary private investigator to solve the mystery.

Secret of the Silver Earring will let you control both Holmes and Dr. Watson across 40 different 19th-century London locations. This mystery is broken up into five parts, and at the end of each one, you will be quizzed by Holmes on the people you have talked to, the places you have been, and the items you’ve collected. He will ask you a question, and you will answer it. You will have to give a brief explanation as to what led to these conclusions as well. Once you have completed the quiz, Holmes will let you know how well you did.

You will also need to utilize Sherlock’s chemistry knowledge at his analysis table at 221B Baker Street. Here you will be able to take the various items you have collected and examine the evidence under a microscope. You can also examine how various objects react with fire or what happens when some chemicals and powders you collect will interact with boiling water.

Now at this point you’re probably feeling a bit overwhelmed. How in the world can you be expected to keep up with all of this data, and know what it all means? As you draw conclusions and make observations, these details will be taken down in your notebook. The notebook also contains all of your conversations as well as the information on various pieces of paper you find. This book becomes one of your most valuable tools as you try to solve the mystery of the Silver Earring.


Difficulty:

Once you get into the mindset of Secret of the Silver Earring and realize that it is more than just picking up objects and using them with others (as is typical with most point-and-click adventures), this game gets a lot easier. If you find yourself stuck in a level and don’t know exactly where you are supposed to go next, then it might be a good idea to go back to the suspicious objects you saw but "needed something else" and measure the object, or have a closer look at it. There are several tools in Holmes’ inventory that will be used over and over again.

A lot of the puzzles are tough and once you get past a level, the quizzes will show you just how much you were able to deduce from the clues that you gathered and the people you talked to.


Game Mechanics:

Secret of the Silver Earring is more than just your typical point-and-click adventure. The need to use certain items to examine other clues makes you have to think just a little bit more about how to use the different items and clues that you gather while trying to find out exactly who murdered Sir Melvyn Bromsby.

Though there are some graphical problems, and the learning curve is troublesome at first -- Silver Earring is a good game that any adventure gamer should be able to find space on the hard drive for. As for those of you who aren’t into the problem-solving aspect of games, you might want to pass this one up.


-J.R. Nip, GameVortex Communications
AKA Chris Meyer

Minimum System Requirements:



Windows 98/ME/2000/XP (only), Pentium III 600 MHz, AMD Athlon (Pentium III 800 MHz or AMD Athlon or higher recommended), 256 MB RAM, 32 MB DirectX 8.1 compliant video card (64 MB 3D-accelerated video card recommended), DirectX 8.1 compliant sound card, DirectX 8.1 or higher (included on disc), 8x CD-ROM (24x recommended), 1.5 GB free hard drive space
 

Test System:



Windows XP Professional Ed., AMD Athlon XP 2400+ 2GHz, 2 GB RAM, DVD-RW, Radeon 9800 Pro, DirectX 9.0b.

GameBoy Color/Pocket Carmageddon Microsoft Xbox Robotech: Invasion

 
Game Vortex :: PSIllustrated